Sugary excerpt of Adam Serwer's post on some 'conservatives's' questionable beliefs about Obama and his family history:
John Podheretz and Peter Wehner argue that whether or not Obama's mother slept with men who weren't white is incidental to the fact that Obama hates America, but Michael Ledeen thinks it's a valid subject for discussion:
The character of our president is an important matter. I think both John and David have tried to illuminate it, but I wish John had taken more time with his latest tirade, gotten the facts right, and focused his considerable talent on the serious matters that rightly concern us.Apparently being attracted to people outside of your own race reflects not just on the character of the parents, but on their children who have no choice in the matter. This kind of racial determinism seems like a lateral movement from the days when conservatives were debating whether or not interracial sex made you love communism. Again, there's a sort of mystical power accorded the phalluses of nonwhite men here that begs some serious psychological analysis from a qualified professional.
Why don't black people vote Republican again?
I'm amazed by Serwer's last question. He implies that it is an abomination for any people with dark skin to vote for republicans because they ought to be single issue voters and solely focus on race to the detriment of economics and any other thing that they believe because race is the only important political issue, the one who defines them and ought to determine their politics. If that isn't racial determinism, I don't know what is. I'm not addressing the views Sewer are excoriating because it isn't just some conservatives who feel that Obama is different because of his background, many liberals and Americans share that perception except that for them it is a positive difference. In my view, it isn't a meaningless different for Obama is as American as George W. Bush. It is thus hypocritical for Serwer to argue that 'conservatives' are the only people who believe that race is all defining and that one is her/his color of skin. In short, Serwer is in fact legitimizing the vision of race that appalls him, racial determinism by making the point implicitly that people shouldn't vote for people who don't share their views of race. As the Church Lady in Dana Carvey's sketch would say, isn't that special !!!!


OK, well, why don't Black people vote Republican? Was it the welfare-bashing, the school-bashing, the single mom-bashing, the mass incarcerating, the Confederate Flag flying, the MLK Day-rejecting or the Strom Thurmond-celebrating?
An individual is necessarily as racialized as the world, society and community in which he or she lives.
Posted by: Craig | Thursday, 15 April 2010 at 04:31 AM
'Black' people don't vote republicans because America is a race country, ones where people believe in race determinism. What Adam Serwer is denouncing is something that he believes in and that the majority in America believes in, he is only denouncing it because of who is exploiting the issue and using that central American belief to suit their point of view.
Posted by: Christelle | Thursday, 15 April 2010 at 10:08 AM