Zenobia of Mind the Gap rebuts Geri Halliwell’s (of the Spice Girls) mindless attack on feminism:
My main issue, though, is with the Guardian. Geri said some pretty bad stuff in that interview. Most obviously, she used "lesbianism" in a pejorative sense. She also did that irritating "let's disown the bra-burning" thing. Now, I've seen footage of that shit, and I think there was nothing wrong with it, in fact it was pretty damn great. But no digressions now. She also thinks feminism would emasculate men, and that we need to reclaim our femininity. Of course, I mean, she's Geri Halliwell. But even cutting her some slack, those are all far, far worse things to say than "Gee, I'm not really sure I'm a feminist, really...". Also, the Guardian did the same thing with Carmen Electra a while ago. And feminism isn't even remotely part of her job description. It's cool if she wants to be a feminist, but I'm certainly not going to lose sleep over it if she isn't.
It's important not to be afraid of the word, of course, and to use it and be proud of the history behind it. But not everyone wants to identify as feminist, quite often for very good reasons of their own. And most of those who aren't feminist, or choose not to self-apply the word, are still contributing plenty to society, and good enough for them. I don't think Missy Elliott is remotely a feminist, but she's doing a lot more for the cause just through being excellent at what she does than a whole truckload full of Pinks, Pipettes and Dittos.
Zenobia puts her finger on the problem with feminism, which is that it is too vague, too narrow, too strict, or too empty depending on your perspective. My critique of feminism focuses on its relevance and on the fact that it doesn’t mean it anything anymore for there is a disconnection between thought, reality, and action. Feminism is like rap. At the beginning, its aim was noble, but it has become superseded by glamour and pop. It is for that reason it is popular either to diss it or to embrace it without deep thoughts because what matters is its history and images and how hip they are perceived to be at the time. Feminism just like socialism (I’m not saying that the two are the same) is dead and t true believers are trying to keep it alive through necromancy. Unfortunately, the trouble with necromancy is that it doesn’t deal with le réel, with the real, it deals with the past and the sacred. Feminism is passé. Those who admire de Beauvoir and the others have to have the courage to admit it and to imagine something else, something with teeth that a pop singer cannot mindlessly and easily criticize and be taken seriously.